With a subtle but noticeable olive oil flavor and a hint of orange, this cake has become my family’s new favorite, and I will be making it again, and again. The olive oil gives it a pleasant fruity flavor while keeping the cake moister for longer than butter ever could. My husband loves the idea of a tender cake sans butter and nearly devoured the entire cake the first time I made it. Even die-hard butter devotees admit this is an exceptional cake.
Thank you to my friend and author, Lise Arin, who shared this recipe with me. She pulled it out of a magazine back in 2013! Her husband, a fabulous cook, usually resists menu suggestions, but in the time of COVID and a mere 7 years later, he acquiesced, and we are so happy he did.
I barely changed the recipe, adding a wonderful nut milk to replace the dairy and a bit of orange zest. This is truly a great recipe—a simple, orange-scented olive oil cake that is an elegant treat for family and guests alike.
Yield: Makes 1 9-inch cake